We have many memories of shared times with Max and Edith over twenty-three years since Brian and Sue became engaged. There have been many life experiences, both happy and sad in which we were joined. Thanksgiving dinners, births of grandchildren, family birthday and anniversary parties,Rosh Hashanah dinners as well as the somber occasions of losses. We will miss his feisty, challenging conversations which grew softer and more sparse in recent years. We recall some very pleasant times during a trip to Florida a number of years ago, enjoying a favorite activity...a meal and good conversation.